Buy It or Skip It: Not All Toys Are Created Equal
Two toys can look almost identical on the shelf but create completely different play experiences. In this edition of my ✅Buy It or ❌Skip It series, I’m comparing picnic baskets, toolboxes, and doctor’s kits to show why I almost always choose the simpler option. Learn how to spot toys that encourage creativity, imaginative play, and problem-solving, and why more features don’t always mean better play.
This blog post may contain affiliate links. When you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products that I genuinely believe can benefit you and your family! Your support helps maintain and improve all things A Pop of You. Thanks so much!
✅ Buy It or ❌ Skip It: Helping You Buy Better, Not More
Walking through the toy aisle (or scrolling Amazon after the kids go to bed) can feel like an impossible task. Every toy promises to build creativity, encourage learning, or become your child’s new favorite. But if you’ve ever spent good money on a toy that was abandoned by lunchtime, you know the reality doesn’t always match the marketing.
That’s exactly why I started my ✅ Buy It or ❌ Skip It series.
As a former teacher, homeschool mom, and someone who’s intentionally simplified our home over the years, I’ve learned that more toys don’t necessarily create better play. In fact, I’ve found the opposite is often true. A thoughtfully chosen collection of toys that truly earn their place in your home almost always leads to more creativity, deeper play, less clutter, and fewer regrets.
In this series, I’m sharing the toys that have stood the test of time in our house, along with the ones I personally wouldn’t buy again. Every recommendation is based on real-life experience, not what’s trending online or what’s sitting at the top of a bestseller list. I look for toys that encourage open-ended play, grow alongside children, support learning and imagination, and continue getting pulled off the shelf months or even years later.
You’ll also see me recommend skipping toys that are overpriced, overly complicated, take up unnecessary space, or lose their appeal almost as quickly as they’re unboxed. Because sometimes the best purchase is the one you never make.
My goal isn’t to convince you to buy more toys. It’s to help you buy better toys. The kind that save you money in the long run, reduce toy overwhelm, support meaningful play, and make your home feel a little calmer in the process.
Each post in this series focuses on a different category of toys to help you make confident, informed decisions before you click “Add to Cart.” I hope these honest recommendations help you build a toy collection your kids truly love, and one you won’t regret bringing into your home.
✅ Buy It or ❌ Skip It #5: Not All Toys Are Created Equal
One of the biggest misconceptions I see when parents are shopping for toys is assuming that if two toys serve the same purpose, they’re equally good choices.
A picnic basket is a picnic basket.
A toolbox is a toolbox.
A doctor’s kit is a doctor’s kit.
Right? Not exactly.
When I walk through the toy aisle, I’m not just looking at what the toy is. I’m looking at how children will interact with it. Does the toy encourage creativity, imagination, and problem-solving? Or does it rely on lights, sounds, and buttons to keep children entertained?
Two toys may appear nearly identical at first glance, but the way children play with them can be completely different. Here are three examples from the Walmart toy aisle.
1. Picnic BasketS: Simple Wins Every Time
✅ Buy: Fisher-Price Wooden Picnic Basket & Food Pretend Play Set
At first glance, the Fisher-Price Wooden Picnic Basket & Food Pretend Play Set and the LeapFrog Shapes & Sharing Picnic Basket seem almost identical. Both include a picnic basket. Both have pretend food. Both are marketed as educational.
But once you watch a child play with them, they’re actually creating two very different experiences.
The wooden picnic basket simply gives children the tools to play. They decide what’s for lunch, who they’re inviting to the picnic, what conversations they’re having, and what happens next. One day they’re feeding stuffed animals. The next day they’re hosting a tea party or opening a pretend restaurant. The toy never changes, but the play does because the child is responsible for creating it.
❌ Skip: LeapFrog Shapes & Sharing Picnic Basket
The LeapFrog version takes a different approach. It lights up, plays music, asks questions, and guides children through activities. While that can certainly capture their attention, it also shifts the focus. Instead of creating the picnic, children often spend their time waiting to see what the toy will do next.
That’s why I’d choose the wooden version every time. I want my child to create the fun, not simply react to it.
2. Toolboxes: Building More Than Pretend Projects
✅ Buy: Fisher-Price Wooden Tool Box
The same idea applies to toy toolboxes. The Fisher-Price Wooden Tool Box is simple, but that’s exactly what makes it so valuable. Children naturally pretend they’re fixing furniture, repairing toys, building houses, or helping Mom and Dad around the house. Every play session looks a little different because they’re inventing the story themselves.
✅ Buy: B. Toys Fix ‘n’ Play Kit
If you’re looking for another great option, I also recommend the B. Toys Fix ‘n’ Play Kit. Like the Fisher-Price version, it encourages open-ended pretend play instead of relying on lights and sounds to keep children entertained. Kids can build, repair, create, and problem-solve while strengthening fine motor skills and using their imaginations. It includes a few more tools and accessories, making it a fun choice for children who love playing “builder” while still encouraging the child, not the toy, to do the work.
❌ Skip: VTech Drill & Learn Toolbox Pro
The VTech Drill & Learn Toolbox Pro is much busier. It lights up, plays songs, asks questions, and rewards children for pressing buttons. While it may seem more educational at first glance, most of the learning is already programmed into the toy.
I’d rather see a child deciding what needs to be fixed than simply pressing a button to hear another sound effect. The wooden toolbox encourages imagination, language development, sequencing, and problem-solving in a way that’s much harder for a performing toy to replicate.
Doctor’s Kits: Match the Toy to the Child
Sometimes my recommendation isn’t “buy” or “skip.” Sometimes it’s “buy the version that’s appropriate for your child’s stage”.
✅ Buy for Kids 3 and Under: Battat Mini Medic Doctor Play Set
For toddlers and younger preschoolers, simpler is almost always better. This doctor kit includes fewer pieces, making it easier to clean up, easier to organize, and much less overwhelming. Young children can focus on pretending to check heartbeats, give bandages, and care for stuffed animals without constantly searching for tiny accessories.
✅ Buy for Kids 4+: Melissa & Doug Get Well Doctor’s Kit
As children get older, their pretend play naturally becomes more detailed. That’s when I love introducing a more comprehensive doctor kit like the Melissa & Doug version. The additional tools inspire more elaborate storytelling while continuing to encourage empathy, communication, vocabulary, sequencing, and imaginative play. It’s a great example of choosing a toy that grows with your child’s developmental stage.
The Bottom Line: It’s Not About More Features
When we’re shopping for toys, it’s easy to assume that more buttons, more lights, more songs, and more technology automatically make a toy better. But I’ve found the opposite is usually true.
The toys that ask the least of children often become the ones children outgrow the fastest. The toys that ask children to imagine, create, pretend, and solve problems are the ones that continue getting pulled off the shelf year after year. That’s why I almost always choose the simpler version. Because one of the biggest lessons I’ve learned after raising three girls is this:
The simpler the toy, the more work the child does.
And that’s exactly what I want.✌🏼
Hey There,
I’m Katelyn!
Hi, I’m Katelyn! Join me for creative, intentional family fun and practical home management tips! Parenting is hard, but I’ve got the tools to help you create a calmer, more intentional home!
BROWSE MY
TOY RECS
resourceS
SHOP LEARNING RESOURCES
Subscribe to the empty mug club
GET OUR DAILY TO-DOS FREE!
Plus, get the latest achievable learning activities, easy recipes, storage solutions, teacher-approved toy suggestions + exclusive discounts to Becoming You learning resources straight to your inbox!
About Katelyn Collier , MAT
Katelyn Collier is a former elementary school teacher turned homeschooling mom of three and the founder of A Pop of You. She’s passionate about helping families step away from the pressure of today’s fast-paced culture and create homes filled with presence, joy, and balance. Through her resources and podcast, she shares simple, practical tools to reclaim childhood and make family life feel lighter and more intentional.
Masters DEgree in elementary education
VOICE OF BECOMING UNPOPULAR, A PODCAST COMING SOON!
CREATOR OF BECOMING YOU, A KIDS’ LEARNING RESOURCE LINE
FIND MORE INSPIRATION
Even More Achievable Ideas
